0 more \ multicoloured mud
It’s hard to please The List’s art critic, but one new exhibition has set him alight. Kennedy explains why Callum lnnes’ paintings play a pivotal role in Scottish art.
s there a place for High Modernist Art in
Scotland? Was there ever? ‘New York stole the
idea of Modern art'. we are told hyperbolically by various writers. ‘and Scotland got left with the Scottish Colourists and their ilk.‘
Scotland has no 20th century fin de siecle truly Modernist and avant-gardist tradition to speak of. (Docs Mackintosh count? Ish.) No abstract explorations of the basic stuff of painting — line. colour. form. surface. etc. Anne Redpath's Matisse inspired works did go some way to shake things up. but not far enough. We did get a hand-painted pop version of Abstract Expressionism in the work of Joan Eardlie. but it was always shackled to subject matter. and Craigie Aitchison tried it. But the closest we got was the multicoloured mud of the Scottish (‘olourists before Paolo/.zi‘s pop pattern version in the (10s. It is no wonder that European High Modernism (think sexy. cooler than thou abstraction) and American Abstract Expressionist ‘colour field~ paintings (kind of the same as the European stuff but bigger) are making a comeback of sons.
What can loosely be referred to as ‘colour field' painting. pioneered by Rothko and Newman et al in 40s American Abstract Expressionism. was a continuation of the experiments with form that had been going on in mainland Europe.
So. can the new show of paintings by Edinburgh- based (‘allum lnnes at the Fruitmarket in Edinburgh be seen as evidence that ‘Edinburgh has stolen back the idea of Modern Art“? What does that mean in 2006? lnnes creates works that would not have looked out of place in a New York gallery ()0 years ago. But these images are not 'copies‘. They do not mimic the compositions of the artists they invoke. They are the depository of formal elements of a tradition. collages in paint that tie the disparate strands of Modernism to the present.
Is this allowed? Are we to pretend that everything from Jasper Johns to the present day didn‘t happen? No Warhol? No Beuys? No Hirst or Emin? If history
was some kind of grand narrative. then this kind of
time travel would not be allowed. It would be seen as old in a world where old=bad. reactionary. But if the ‘new" is a myth invented in a think tank by market researchers. and history is in process and is continually being re-written. then there is a place for these ‘quotations‘. Only if they are good. of course. And lnnes' paintings are exceptionally good. It would be totally wrong to suggest that lnnes‘ works are ‘copies’. That would give the illusion that there was an ‘original' in a pristine historical context waiting to
be plundered. What is true is that art created after
modernism exploits a temporal fold of the kind which allows lnnes' painting to operate. Like crime novelists after Agatha Christie. it‘s perfectly possible
10 THE LIST 19 Oct—2 Nov 2006
HAS CALLUM INNES STOLEN BACK THE IDEA OF MODERN ART?
to work within a framework of ideas. but to be totally different from its original pioneers.
A recent exhibition of work at Glasgow‘s 'I‘ramway by the Young British Artist Keith (‘oventry shows how not to do it. His ironic take on the European Modernist tradition looked sophomoric. and suffered from that which it tried to critique: the notion of the artist as hero and myth maker. a conduit for the sublime. He acted as a knowing channel for a skeptical take on things. but still floated above it all like a transcendental subject. He seemed to find the Utopian element of Modernism hilariously naive and ideologically dodgy. It is there. of course. but the
artists usually came down on the side of socialist or
communist doctrines rather than fascism. The Nazis thought most of it was degenerate and burnt great heaps of the stuff. (‘oventry’s ‘one liner art' is very thin in this respect — there’s one dull. glib. supposedly
witty thought underpinning his take on
art that makes you snort: it temporarily makes you think you are clever because you can laugh along at the artist‘s joke. But you walk away not giving a damn.
By contrast. lnnes’ new exhibition.
continues an impressive lineage of
formalist explorations into what painting is. In each
canvas we see lessons learnt in the abstract work of
some of the most significant painters. If it isn‘t Rothko‘s rich colour fields with soft but detailed edges it is Newman‘s zips as the absence of paint. Pollock‘s chained chaos and lyricism or Kelly‘s throbbing. pure colours. At its best. it presents the most difficult passages of Modernist painting. made to look easy.
Fruitmarket Gallery, Edinburgh, until Sun 19 Nov
Monologue Nine
the modernist tradition. It‘s the kind of
PLUCKING FRUITS FROM THE CULTURAL BUSH
I The hottest hotseat is showbusiness keeps on hotting up with fervent rumours about the replacement for Des Lynam in the reclining Countdown chair. Carol Vorderman is still refusing to be considered a candidate while Stephen Fry is the latest name to get chucked into the ring. . . And word has it that the Beeb might be looking for a new Doctor Who after David Tennant does his second full stint next spring . . . Paddy Considine may not be in the running to be the new Timelord or the next word guru but he has signed up to join the cast of The Bourne Ultimatum. Our humble assassin in the shape of Matt Damon will still be trying to piece together his former life while Considine is to play a journalist on the hunt of a former CIA director . . . My Chemical Romance have announced details of a UK tour which takes in Glasgow SECC next March. Better bone up on their new longplayer The Black Parade then . . . You could have placed a sizeable bet on the autobiography of snooker's living (just) legend Alex Higgins having a certain word in its title. And you'd have done rather well out of it. From the Eye of the Hurricane is due out next spring . . . Joseph Fiennes has just signed up to play composer Antonio Vivaldi in a forthcoming biopic which also stars Malcolm McDowell and Jacqueline Bisset . . . The follow-up to 2004 's Street Disciple will see Nas being joined by a galaxy of rap stars. December‘s Hip Hop is Dead: The N ' is set to feature Kanye West. Dr Dre and The Game.