Mailbox The List, 14 High Street, Edinburgh EH1 1TE or The List at the CCA 350 Sauchiehall Street, Glasgow G2 3JD or email letters@list.co.uk

HOUSE PROUD Re: The House of Bernarda Alba One of the best plays I have ever seen superb! Has you laughing one minute, crying the next, but mostly laughing at their patter. The cast are brill, especially so Siobhan Redmond and Myra McFadyen. You will love it. Get tickets while you still can. Parrs, Glasgow Comment posted at List.co.uk FAITH NO MORE Re: Richard Dawkins The Greatest Show on Earth RD is kind of like the intelligent adult's JK Rowling without the serialisation. I'm looking forward to reading this. Psalms may think atheists to be fools, but atheists think fools are born of being foolish. Quote a book with talking snakes and seas being parted and virgins giving birth, and believe it is factually true? How foolish would that be? Santa, North Pole, Alaska Comment posted at List.co.uk

Monty Python already did this bit in The Meaning of Life. Susan Those who dismiss evolution don't understand that it makes no claims for or against the existence of God. It simply

LETTER OF THE FORTNIGHT

AND JUSTICE FOR ALL Re: File sharing So, prompted by Lily Allen's recent blog on the subject, self- styled, edgy style bible NME has finally come round to the opinion that file sharing, or downloading music illegally call it what you will might actually be a morally bad thing, and thus something that people SHOULD actually feel shameful about.

Fair enough you could accuse them of arriving at this viewpoint for entrely selfish reasons, given that it’s their very lifeblood new music that file sharing discourages the creation of in removing a revenue stream of any upcoming musicians.

However, the case for appealing to people’s morals remains strong, and whether the 'content wants to be free' brigade like it or not, music has costs associated with its creation, and isn't 'information' we have a right to access either it's entertainment, therefore a luxury. Not paying for it just because it's very easy to do so and get away with it should be viewed in the same way as the old trick of slipping a pack of smoked salmon into your magazine at the supermarket checkout. Or was it just me that used to do that? Michael, Edinburgh

THE LETTER OF THE ISSUE WILL RECEIVE ONE BOTTLE OF THE BLACK GROUSE WHISKY Smoky and Smooth a marriage of fine peated Scotch malt whiskies and The Famous Grouse

explains the development of life without the need for intervention by one. Glenister M And the wise man hath said it out loud. 'Nuff said. Kimpatsu, Tokyo

Psalm 14:1 ‘The FOOL says in his heart, “There is no God”’. Jimmy2820, Lanarkshire If even the fool says there's no God, what's your problem? CiG, Warwickshire

Matthew 5:22 ‘But whosoever shall say, Thou Fool shall be in danger of hell fire’. Ewan D, Edinburgh

I pity the fool. BA Baracus, Los Angeles

BEGGAR BELIEF Re: The Beggar's Opera Great set design, costumes, AV and band. Sandy Grierson as MacHeath was really convincing. Tasty eye candy too. Well worth a visit. Xerrex, Edinburgh Comment posted at List.co.uk

IN A BIG COUNTRY Re: Bruce & Jamie Watson Friday's gig at Lathones by Bruce and Jamie Watson was amazing. What a great gig! Fantastic venue for a start and the crowd was made up of enthusiastic fans from not only all over the UK (hi to the Welsh guys) but also from the US, Denmark, Finland and Australia from what I could gather. Bruce was hilarious

between tracks and he and Jamie gave awesome performances of both new songs and a few reworked Big Country tracks. They both obviously love performing and the crowd were with them all the way! Jooks, Scotland Comment posted at List.co.uk

Next issue out Wednesday 7 October

Technology The cultural landscape is changing faster than you can say on demand content delivery service, and it’s a confusing new world we’re now peering at from behind our Apple Macs. The List is on hand with our comprehensive technology guide to make things just a little bit simpler. Feminism One hundred years on from the historic suffragette march through Edinburgh centre, we examine the current state of the feminist cause.

YOU’VE GOT 15 DAYS TO LIVE 96 THE LIST 24 Sep–8 Oct 2009

CONTRIBUTORS Publisher & General Editor Robin Hodge Director Simon Dessain EDITORIAL Editor Jonny Ensall Deputy Editor Mark Robertson Assistant Editor Kirstin Innes, Henry Northmore, Allan Racliffe Subeditor Hamish Brown Research Manager Suzanne Black Research Siân Bevan, Tasmin Campbell, Rosalie Doubal, Henry Northmore, David Pollock, Fiona Shepherd SALES & MARKETING Advertising Sales Manager Brigid Kennedy Senior Media Sales Executive Juliet Tweedie Media Sales Executive Aimi Gold, Jess McGrath Business Development Executive Adam Coulson Business Development Manager Brendan Miles Sponsorship & Promotions Manager Sheri Friers (Maternity leave) Carine Seitz Promotions Executive Amy Russell Circulation Executive Murray Robertson PRODUCTION Art Director Krista Robertson (Maternity leave) Senior Designer Lucy Munro Production Manager Simon Armin Production Assistant Miriam Sturdee DIGITAL Web Editor Hamish Brown Senior Developer Andy Carmichael Senior Designer Bruce Combe Software Developer Iain McCusker Web Editorial Assistant Thomas Meek

ADMINISTRATION Accounts Manager Georgette Renwick Accounts Assistant Tasmin Campbell Office & HR Manager Jo Morgan Glasgow Office Manager Sharon Stephen Reception Amy Russell SECTION EDITORS Around Town Kirstin Innes Books Brian Donaldson Clubs Henry Northmore Comedy Brian Donaldson Dance Kelly Apter Eat & Drink Donald Reid Film Paul Dale Kids Kelly Apter LGBT Allan Radcliffe Music Mark Robertson News Anna Millar Shopping Kirstin Innes Theatre Allan Radcliffe Travel Kirstin Innes Visual Art Allan Radcliffe